How To Store Peach Cobbler Overnight?

How to store peach cobbler overnight? Or, do you need to refrigerate the peach cobbler? We are going to find answers to these questions in our article.

Peach cobbler is a mouthwatering delicacy made of caramelized peach and a topping of biscuit. It is also particularly easy to make. Most often, it will be get eaten on the day it is made. But – what if you cannot finish it somehow? What do you do with the remaining peach cobbler? Should you refrigerate it or look for other ways of storing it?

Storing Peach Cobbler

The peach cobbler will last for only 2 days in the open. Afterward, you have to put it in the fridge which extends its life for further 2 days. However, the topping may become mushy or soggy. Freezing will make peach cobbler last for at least 3 to 4 months and therefore, it is also a good option.

Can I leave peach cobbler overnight as well? Yes, it will not go bad for two days even if you don’t refrigerate it. Therefore, you can leave it overnight and eat it in the morning.

The best way to store peach cobbler is to use a plastic container. You can easily find these on Amazon or other online retailers.

Reasons to Refrigerate Peach Cobbler

Do you have to refrigerate peach cobbler? You can leave it out of the fridge at room temperature for 2 days. But – not in a hot and humid room otherwise, it will go bad earlier than 48 hours. Your peach cobbler will also get mushy and be worthless. Therefore, you should refrigerate it if your home or kitchen is hot and humid.

Read more: How Long Is Spaghetti Sauce Good In The Fridge

How Long Can a Peach Cobbler be Refrigerated?

You can store peach cobbler in the fridge for up to 96 hours or 4 days. Therefore, it is better to put it in the fridge if nobody is going to eat it in the next 2 days. It will also give you 2 extra days. However, freshly made peach cobbler will always taste better than the refrigerated one.

Peach cobbler can also absorb moisture in the fridge. You can prevent it by wrapping the container. It can get soggy if it moisture continues to get in. You can individually wrap each portion of the cobbler as well.

Can You Freeze Peach Cobbler?

Yes, you can always freeze the peach cobbler. It is an excellent option if you are not going to eat it in the next few days. Similarly, it also enables you to store it in batches. Frozen cobbler can last for 3 to 4 months without compromising on quality and flavor. All you need to do is to freeze it in an airtight container, preferably a plastic container.

How to Store Peach Cobbler?

We all know how to store peach cobbler overnight. But – how to store it for a long time? The storage methods are slightly different for two major kinds of cobbler that are cobblers with a biscuit topping and cobblers with crumble or pie crust topping.

Biscuit Topping Peach Cobblers

You should always bake the cobbler before you freeze it in the case of biscuit topping. However, baked peach cobbler can become mushy in the freezer because of the moisture. You can prevent this to happen by:

  • Ensuring that peach cobbler is fully cooled before you put it in the freezer
  • Always store peach cobbler in an airtight container
  • Cover the peach cobbler with some baking paper under the container cover. It will prevent ice crystals to form resulting in fresh and tasty cobbler even after months.

Crumble or Pie Crush Cobblers

You can freeze the peach cobbler before or after baking if it has pie crust or crumble topping.

Put the beach cobbler that you froze before baking in the oven when you want to eat it. Now heat it for 20 minutes longer than it usually takes to bake a peach cobbler. The result will be an incredibly fresh and delicious cobbler.

How to Tell if Peach Cobbler is Bad?

Peach cobbler does not last as long as some other delights, unfortunately. The following are some telltale signs that it has gone bad.

Change in Texture

The first sign is the change in texture. It will go mushy and soggy as it starts to get bad. It is better to throw it away when these signs appear.

Read more: Can You Freeze Chicken Soup

Mold Development

Throw your peach cobbler into the trash the moment you see the visible mold.


One of the easiest tips to find out if the cobbler is bad is to do a smell test, especially if it has been stored for days. It can be spoiled even if it looks good and therefore, it is better to smell it before eating.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it OK to leave cobbler out overnight?

You can leave freshly made dessert overnight or for an entire day and it will not go bad. However, you should keep it away from sunlight, moisture, and heat. Similarly, it should contain eggs or dairy otherwise it will go bad.

Can you make a cobbler the night before?

Yes, you can make batches of peach cobbler even 48 hours before time. But – keep the peach filling and the topping separate before baking. It will become soggy if you keep them together.

Does homemade peach cobbler need to be refrigerated?

Yes, you should refrigerate homemade peach cobbler if you don’t want to eat it right away. You can keep it in the fridge for up to 4 days without making it soggy or mushy.

How long can peach cobbler sit out?

It can last for up to 2 days without going bad according to the USDA. However, it is better to put leftover cobbler in the fridge to get additional 2 days.

Final Thoughts

Invented by early English settlers out of necessity, peach cobbler is an extremely delicious dish. It is also quite easy to make and store. You can even make it in advance and keep it in the open for up to 2 days. However, putting it in the fridge and freezing can give you extra 2 days or 3 months respectively. All you need to do is to store it properly in an airtight container otherwise it will get soggy even in a fridge or freezer.

Leave a Comment